Real-Time Payments vs ACH: A Comprehensive Comparison for Modern Payments
In today's digital world, it's essential to choose the right payment method for your needs. Whether you're a business owner or an individual, understanding the different payment systems available can help you make informed decisions. Two of the most commonly used payment methods are Real-Time Payments (RTP) and Automated Clearing House (ACH) transfers. While they both serve the same purpose of moving money from one place to another, they function quite differently. This article will explain what RTP and ACH are, how they work, and how they differ from each other.
Real-time payments vs. ACH: What are the differences?
What Are Real-Time Payments (RTP)?
Real-Time Payments (RTP) are exactly what they sound like—payments that happen in real time. When you use RTP, the money is transferred almost instantly from one account to another. This system operates 24/7, meaning you can send or receive payments at any time, even on weekends or holidays.
RTP is widely used for transactions that require immediate transfer of funds. For example, if you need to pay someone quickly or if a business wants to provide instant refunds to customers, RTP is the ideal choice. The speed and convenience make it a popular option for many people and businesses alike.
What Are Automated Clearing House (ACH) Transfers?
Automated Clearing House (ACH) transfers are a bit different from RTP. ACH is a network that processes payments in batches, typically during regular business hours. Because of this, ACH transfers usually take longer—often one to three business days—to complete.
ACH is commonly used for transactions like direct deposit of paychecks, automatic bill payments, and business-to-business transactions. It's a reliable method that has been around for a long time, and its slower processing times are often balanced by its lower costs, making it a good choice for less urgent payments.
Both Real-Time Payments (RTP) and Automated Clearing House (ACH) transfers are experiencing rapid growth as more people and businesses move away from cash transactions. However, ACH remains the dominant player in the field. According to the Federal Reserve, the total value of noncash payments in 2021 reached a staggering $128.51 trillion, with ACH payments contributing to 90% of the growth in noncash transactions. This highlights the widespread adoption and trust in the ACH system, which continues to handle a vast majority of payment volumes despite the rising popularity of RTP.
Pros and Cons of Real-Time Payments
Pros:
- Immediate transfer of funds.
- Available 24/7, including holidays and weekends.
- Useful for urgent or time-sensitive payments.
Cons:
- Higher transaction fees compared to ACH.
- Increased risk of errors or fraud due to the speed of transactions.
- Not yet universally available in all regions or banks.
Pros and Cons of ACH Payments
Pros:
- Lower transaction costs, especially for recurring payments.
- Widely accepted and used by businesses and individuals.
- Suitable for large-volume transactions.
Cons:
- Slower processing times—can take one to three business days.
- Limited to business hours, excluding weekends and holidays.
- Potential delays in payment clearance.
Common Use Cases for ACH vs. Real-Time Payments (RTP)
When it comes to choosing between ACH and RTP, understanding the most common applications of each can help in making the right decision.
ACH Use Cases:
- Bill Pay: ACH is frequently used for paying bills, thanks to its reliable and consistent processing.
- Employee Salary: Many businesses rely on ACH to handle payroll, ensuring employees receive their salaries on time.
- Larger B2B Purchases: For substantial business-to-business transactions, ACH is a preferred method due to its cost-effectiveness and security.
- Paying Taxes: ACH is a common method for paying taxes, providing a secure way to handle these crucial transactions.
- Moving Funds Between Accounts: Transferring money between accounts within the same or different banks is often done through ACH.
RTP Use Cases:
- Instant Payouts from Apps: Apps like Venmo often use RTP to offer instant payouts to users, usually for a small fee.
- Payouts from Gig Economy Apps: Gig workers may receive instant payments via RTP from platforms like Uber or Lyft.
- Refunds and Warranty Payments: Companies may use RTP to provide quick refunds or warranty payouts to customers.
- Instant Bank Transfers: RTP is ideal for situations where immediate bank transfers are necessary.
- Instant Payroll: Some businesses use RTP to offer employees the option of receiving their pay instantly.
|
Use Case |
ACH |
RTP |
|
Bill Pay |
✔️ |
|
|
Employee Salary |
✔️ |
|
|
Larger B2B Purchases |
✔️ |
|
|
Paying Taxes |
✔️ |
|
|
Moving Funds Between Accounts |
✔️ |
|
|
Instant Payouts from Apps |
✔️ (e.g., Venmo, for a fee) |
|
|
Payouts from Gig Economy Apps |
✔️ (e.g., Uber, Lyft) |
|
|
Refunds and Warranty Payments |
✔️ |
|
|
Instant Bank Transfers |
✔️ |
|
|
Instant Payroll |
✔️ |
Speed Comparison: ACH vs. Real-Time Payments (RTP)
ACH Payments:
ACH payments traditionally take anywhere from several hours to a few days to settle. The delay is due to the batch processing system used by the ACH network, where transactions are collected and processed together at specific times during the day. This slower pace can be a drawback for transactions that require quick settlement, such as emergency payments or other time-sensitive transfers.
In response to the increasing demand for faster transactions, the ACH network introduced Same-Day ACH, which allows for quicker processing of payments, typically within the same business day. However, even with this enhancement, Same-Day ACH does not offer the immediate fund availability that RTP does, making it less ideal for situations where speed is absolutely critical.
Real-Time Payments (RTP):
RTP offers instant payment processing, meaning funds are transferred and available immediately, regardless of the time or day. This real-time capability is particularly valuable for use cases where timing is crucial, such as emergency payments, gig economy payouts, and other transactions where the recipient needs immediate access to funds.
Why Speed Matters?
The speed of payment processing is a significant factor in choosing between ACH and RTP. While ACH remains a dominant electronic payment method in the United States, particularly for transactions like payroll, bill payments, and larger B2B transactions, the rise of fintech and the growing demand for faster, more efficient payments have highlighted the need for real-time options.
For many businesses and individuals, RTP is now the preferred choice for transactions where immediate settlement is essential. Despite the improvements brought by Same-Day ACH, RTP's ability to settle instantly makes it the go-to solution for scenarios where time is of the essence.
Choosing the Right Payment Method
Deciding between RTP and ACH depends on your specific needs. If speed is crucial, RTP is the best option. However, if you are looking for a cost-effective solution for regular transactions, ACH might be more suitable. Some businesses and individuals might even choose to use both methods, depending on the situation. Understanding your priorities—whether it's speed, cost, or convenience—will help you decide which payment method is the best fit for you.
Conclusion
Both Real-Time Payments (RTP) and Automated Clearing House (ACH) transfers are valuable tools for moving money, but they serve different purposes. RTP is perfect for instant payments that need to happen immediately, while ACH is better suited for scheduled transactions that aren't time-sensitive. By understanding the differences between these two methods, you can choose the right one for your needs, ensuring that your payments are handled efficiently and effectively.
Talk to Our Expert
Our Services
ISO 20022 (MT to MX) Adoption & Migration
FTM For Corporate Payment Services
IBM Cloud Park For Integration (CP4i)